Earthrid
Music
Artists
FAQ
Help
News
Contact
Links

Review by Y. Arkadin

Published in Erebus online magazine

The following review of our debut release was written by Y. Arkadin for the Webzine Erebus, a review of dark music (mainly Metal, funnily enough!). The site has now been closed by its former editor, but since the review was particularly perceptive we are hosting it again here in the hope that it may be of help to potential listeners, and indeed owners of the CD who may be baffled about the unusual sounds they are hearing!

The opinions expressed on this page are those of this particular reviewer, and we don't necessarily endorse the musical comparisons or impressions he offers. Many thanks to Yury for allowing us to include the review on this site.

Carya Amara - Vestigial Digital (CA01CD)

 [ cover ]

Buy the CD direct from this site.

For Erebus, it is not altogether frequent, let's say, that I receive CDs that deviate far from the confines of the metal genre, so it is always pleasant to hear something new from other spectrums of music. The only one condition that exists for Erebus, I would think, is that the music remains dark, provocative and challenging on some level. With Carya Amara, all three of these requirements are satisfied, but in a way that I cannot openly confess to understand completely. The first thing that I think of when I hear this is the Hafler Trio, second, some minimalist composers like Bertrand Gunter, and third... I don't know what exactly.

There are parts here equal to what you would expect on a serene ambient or new age recording, while others would fit more aptly on a Japanese noise album. There are some elements of post-rock to it as well, maybe, but it seems more and more obvious as I type this that stamping it flatly as such-and-such is completely impossible. Carya Amara specializes in the avant-garde, the way it was done a decade or two ago, and later abandoned. In this sense, listening to Vestigial Digital gives me as much of a nostalgic perception as it does of a futuristic one. I remember first hearing Monte Cazazza and the Hafler Trio years ago - the great disorientation I felt then, and the immense happiness of finding a new form of music I enjoyed. Of course, the impact and the shock is gone now, and this applies as well to Carya Amara, yet there is nonetheless a challenging and refreshing quality to this disc that makes me return to it every now and then.

This recording, in a sense, summarizes the confusion and chaos of the early 21st century, as much as it emphasizes a certain technological progress and stability of recent times through its electronic explorations. Perhaps it is inaccurate to mention the 21st century, as all of the material was recorded from 1996 to 1998. Yet, again, it does offer this impression. As the booklet states, "all tracks use natural and unnatural sounds, processed using a variety of computer software". No synthesizers - strangely - we are told, were used in the process. Very "post-modern", I must say. The artwork is comprised of photographs of wind farms and their rotating structures from several angles. This theme of wind farms I find quite interesting having seen these towering wind generating machines pictured here the first time in Germany last year, and having been left highly impressed by their futuristic presence. The last three tracks on Vestigial Digital, 'Wind Versus Windscale' were directly influenced by wind farms, and were recorded on-location on one of these farms in Kirby Moor (England, I presume) and on a beach near Sellafield, "on", I quote, "the shores of the world's most radioactive sea". The first track, 'Blowy Day' opens with an atmospheric passage of feet stomping and brushing through the grass, a soft groaning purr in the background of the colossal wind machines, that abruptly passes to close-proximity noise, before degenerating in a strange way. The next is an electronic noise piece, 'On The Beach', that sounds something like a Geiger meter going out of a control, if it could produce (a recordable) sound, and the last, 'The Tao of Power', is a more subtle, amorphous ambient work.

For all of its eccentric originality, in the themes and in the sound, Carya Amara possesses a distinguishing atmosphere and taste. This type of thing is not for everyone. There is nothing overtly "musical" about Carya Amara, in the strict conventional use of the term. But it regardless possesses a secret harmony, a reckless boldness and unconcern for established order, that I have found quite intriguing. Check it out, if you can.

Review © 2002 Yury Arkadin
Hear extracts from Vestigial Digital and order online if you're intrigued by what you hear!


Valid HTML 
4.0!